Fagansville (after pioneer Richardson Fagin), commonly known today as Carthage,  was settled in the mid 1780s by Scottish migrants.  They planted roots on the highest hill in the time, standing 900 feet above sea level.  In 1785, the county’s first courthouse was built on Killetts Creek.

In 1796 a legislative committee elected a town to serve as a county seat with an official courthouse at the center of the county.  The courthouse was renamed Carthage.  By 1814, the courthouse was moved to the its current location at the very top of the high hill.  After a series of rebuilds due to collapses and fires, the courthouse was rebuilt in 1922 and still stands today, as the historic courthouse in the center of the traffic circle.

Carthage’s growth from the 1850s to the 1920s was largely due to buggy manufacturing.  In 1856, Thomas Tyson and Alexander Kelly bought a small wheelwright business.  Tyson and Kelly transformed their shop into one of the most well known carriage manufacturers in the United States, known as Tyson and Jones Buggy.  By 1890 they were turning out about 3,000 carriages per year, and developed the reputation of producing the “cadillac of carriages.”  The factory was the largest in the county well into the 20th century.  However, the invention of the automobile brought buggy production to a halt and the last carriage was delivered in 1925.

Carthage NC


Driving through Carthage today, the beautiful, old houses still stand representing the expansive prosperity that Tyson and Jones Buggy brought to the community.  That history is celebrated every spring at the Annual Buggy Festival in the town square around the historical courthouse.  Residents parade hot rods, old tractors and Tyson and Jones buggies.

Carthage NC

Today, Carthage’s population is about 2,300 residents.  The population is spread out with 21.5% under the age of 18, 7.9% from 18 to 24, 26.5% from 25 to 44, 21.9% from 45 to 64, and 22.2% who are 65 years of age or older. The median age is 40 years old. The median income for a family is $43,594.


Carthage Subdivisions

  • Berryfield
  • Cabin Branch
Cabin Branch Carthage NC
  • Carolina Equestrian
  • Deer Trail
  • Dundee Estates
  • Forest Ridge
Forest Ridge Carthage NC
  • Glendon
  • Little River
Little River Carthage NC
  • Savannah’s Garden
Savannah's Garden Carthage NC
  • Tyson Woods
  • Willow Brook
  • Winding Creek